Saturday, November 23
    News Junkie Paradise – Whatfinger News - More news daily than any other news site on Earth - CLICK HERE

    Ukraine’s Incursion into Kursk – A Tactical Win, But Strategic Challenges Remain

    nephilaBy World News 6 Mins Read

    As of August 2024, the conflict between Russia and Ukraine remains intense, with significant developments in the Kursk region of Russia. Ukrainian forces have launched incursions into this area, marking one of the most substantial foreign operations on Russian soil since World War II. The situation has led to heavy redeployment of Russian military units, including conscripts and specialized forces, to counter these advances. Ukrainian President Zelenskyy has asserted that these operations are critical to Ukraine’s broader military objectives.

    1. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy: “We are advancing not only for our sovereignty but for the freedom of all people who wish to live without oppression.”
    2. Russian First Deputy Permanent Representative to the UN Dmitry Polyansky: “Ukraine deserves nothing but total defeat and unconditional capitulation in response to its actions.”

    These quotes explores the deeply entrenched positions on both sides, with no immediate signs of a diplomatic resolution. The conflict continues to escalate, with both military and political maneuvers intensifying​ (Institute for the Study of War).

    Ukraine’s unexpected cross-border raid into Russia’s Kursk region last week took Russian President Vladimir Putin and his military by surprise. Some observers are already speculating that this could be a pivotal moment in the Ukraine war, with parallels being drawn to the historic World War II Battle of Kursk, where Russian and German forces clashed in one of the largest tank battles ever fought.

    In 1943, the Battle of Kursk was a decisive engagement in the history of warfare, and according to American academic Walter Clemens, the current fighting in the same region might carry a significant message: “The 2024 Battle of Kursk warns the Putin regime: Your tyranny is fragile and cannot continue on its present track.”

    For the past week, elite Ukrainian units from four brigades have been expanding their foothold inside Russia, marking the first invasion of Russian territory since World War II. On Monday, Ukraine’s Commander-in-Chief Oleksandr Syrskyi announced that Ukrainian forces had seized nearly 1,000 square kilometers of territory within Russia. “We continue to conduct an offensive operation in the Kursk region,” Syrskyi stated in a video posted on President Volodymyr Zelenskyy’s social media channels.

    Russia’s defense ministry eventually acknowledged that Ukrainian troops had advanced up to 30 kilometers into the Kursk region. This admission came only after Russian pro-war military bloggers criticized the defense ministry’s attempts to downplay the incursion, highlighting how Ukraine easily bypassed border defenses manned by inexperienced conscripts and how sluggishly Russia deployed reinforcements. Even Russia Today, a Kremlin-controlled media outlet, questioned how such a significant breach was allowed to occur, though much of its coverage has focused on the humanitarian response for the region’s 180,000 evacuees.

    In just a few days, this operation has showcased Ukraine’s enduring offensive capabilities, challenging the notion that modern high-tech battlefields are fully transparent. The incursion is a textbook example of combined arms warfare—an area where Western military officials had previously criticized Ukraine’s performance during a less successful counteroffensive last summer. The operational secrecy and speed of the incursion have drawn comparisons to Ukraine’s successful recapture of territory in Kharkiv in the fall of 2022.

    However, despite the success of the Kursk incursion, questions remain about its potential to destabilize Putin’s regime. Zelenskyy suggested on Monday that this operation could signal the beginning of the end for Putin’s rule. His statement coincided with renewed pleas for Western allies to permit Ukraine to use long-range missiles deeper inside Russia.

    Yet, Zelenskyy’s objectives differ from those of historical conquerors. He is not aiming to invade Russia but rather to protect Ukraine from ongoing Russian aggression. The incursion into Kursk likely has more limited goals, such as forcing Russia to redeploy troops from the Donetsk region, where its offensive has been slowly progressing. Indeed, U.S. officials reported on Tuesday that Russia had begun shifting units in response.

    Against the backdrop of increased calls for peace talks from Western nations, Ukraine’s cross-border raid seems designed to strengthen its bargaining position. Zelenskyy emphasized that “Russia must be forced into peace if Putin wants to continue waging war so badly.” His adviser, Mykhailo Podolyak, was more direct, stating that the incursion would enhance Ukraine’s position in any future negotiations with Moscow.

    While the Kursk incursion has caused embarrassment for the Kremlin, it is unlikely to trigger Putin’s downfall. In fact, it might even bolster his position, much like the apartment bombings in Russian cities in 1999, which led to a surge in Putin’s popularity and the start of the Second Chechen War. The Kremlin is already using the incursion to support its narrative that the West and NATO are the real aggressors, playing into Russia’s deep-rooted fears of encirclement by enemies.

    Historically, Russian soldiers have fought more out of patriotism than out of love for their leaders, as seen during World War II. Despite significant losses and incompetent leadership, patriotism and Soviet ideology helped sustain the Soviet Union’s military efforts. Today, Russia’s numerical advantage over Ukraine, which is struggling with mobilization and morale, remains a significant factor. Western allies need to acknowledge this and provide more substantial and timely support if they want to prevent the war from dragging on indefinitely.

    While the Kursk incursion has boosted Ukrainian morale and could rally wavering allies, without more advanced weaponry and the removal of restrictions on long-range missile use, it is difficult to see how Ukraine can shift the broader strategic balance in its favor. Moreover, with Moscow warning that such actions could provoke a wider conflict, fears of escalation may cause hesitation in pushing a nuclear-armed rogue state too far.

    Major Points:

    • Ukraine’s surprise incursion into Russia’s Kursk region marks the first invasion of Russian territory since World War II, catching Russian leadership off guard.
    • The operation demonstrates Ukraine’s capability in combined arms warfare and serves to boost Ukrainian morale, though its strategic aims appear limited.
    • Despite the incursion’s impact, experts caution against overestimating its potential to destabilize Putin’s regime, comparing it to historical instances where Russian patriotism has bolstered leadership.
    • The incursion likely aims to force Russia into redeploying forces, strengthening Ukraine’s position in potential peace talks, rather than signaling a bid to conquer Russian territory.
    • Without significant increases in Western military support, including long-range missiles, Ukraine may struggle to shift the broader strategic balance in its favor.

    Charles William III – Reprinted with permission of Whatfinger News

    Keep Reading

    Add A Comment

    Leave A Reply